Skip to content

Sprained or Broken? How to Tell, and When You Need an X-Ray

Hombre con dolor de espalda y cuello: ¿Hueso roto o esguince? Conozca la diferencia

Medically reviewed by the ER of White Rock Clinical Team |

Updated: November 13, 2026

Table of Contents

You usually cannot tell a sprain from a broken bone for certain without an X-ray. Most ankle injuries turn out to be sprains. Emergency physicians use a short, well-tested checklist, the Ottawa ankle and foot rules, to decide who needs an X-ray (here is how long ER X-ray results take). This guide walks you through it, plus the signs that mean you should come in now.

“The majority of ankle injuries are sprains; fewer than 15 percent of ED X-rays reveal fractures.”

Arun Sayal, MD, emergency physician, in Tips for Catching Commonly Missed Ankle Injuries (ACEP Now)

Sprain or Fracture: What Is the Difference After an Ankle Injury?

A sprain is an injury to a ligament, the tissue that connects bones at a joint. MedlinePlus describes it as “a stretched or torn ligament.” A fracture is a break or crack in the bone itself.

The trouble is that both cause pain, swelling, and bruising. The NIH’s arthritis and musculoskeletal institute lists sudden pain, heavy swelling, and trouble bearing weight as signs of a serious injury. That overlap is why a quick look is rarely enough.

Signs That Point to a Broken Bone

MedlinePlus lists these symptoms of a broken bone:

  • A limb or joint that looks out of place or misshapen
  • Swelling, bruising, or bleeding
  • Pain that may be severe
  • Numbness and tingling
  • Broken skin with bone showing through
  • Trouble moving the limb, or being unable to put weight on the leg

Pain right on the bone matters most. Pressing gently along the bone and finding one sharp, sore spot is more worrying than a general ache around the joint.

The Checklist ER Doctors Use: The Ottawa Ankle and Foot Rules

Emergency physicians in Ottawa, Canada developed these rules in the early 1990s and tested them in JAMA. Before the rules, their team found that more than 95% of patients with ankle injuries got X-rays, yet 85% of those films showed no fracture. Using the rules cut ankle X-rays by 28%, according to lead author Dr. Ian Stiell.

An ankle X-ray is recommended when there is ankle pain plus any of these, as a 2022 review sets them out:

  • Bone tenderness along the back edge or tip of the outer ankle bone, within the lowest 6 cm (about 2.5 inches)
  • Bone tenderness along the back edge or tip of the inner ankle bone, within the same 6 cm
  • Being unable to take four steps right after the injury and again when examined

A foot X-ray is recommended when there is pain in the middle of the foot plus any of these:

  • Bone tenderness at the base of the fifth metatarsal, the bony bump halfway along the outer edge of the foot
  • Bone tenderness at the navicular, the bone on the inner top of the foot just in front of the ankle
  • Being unable to take four steps

The rules are very good at catching breaks. A BMJ review of 27 studies found they picked up 98% of ankle fractures and 99% of midfoot fractures. Doctors apply them during a hands-on exam, so use them at home only as a guide to how seriously to take an injury.

Can a Fracture Hide on a Normal X-Ray (an Occult Fracture)?

Yes, sometimes. Some breaks are too fine to show on the first X-ray, especially small bones in the wrist.

“From a diagnostic point of view, we must appreciate that while X-rays are good tests, they are not perfect. It is well-recognized that 20 to 30 percent of scaphoid fractures are radiographically occult.”

Arun Sayal, MD, emergency physician, in Tips for Diagnosing Occult Fractures in the Emergency Department (ACEP Now)

The scaphoid is a small wrist bone, and “occult” means the break does not show on the first X-ray. That is why you may leave with a splint and a follow-up plan even when your X-ray looks normal. It protects a break that may show up later.

What to Do Right Now

MedlinePlus recommends these first aid steps for a suspected broken bone:

  1. Check the person’s breathing and responsiveness first.
  2. Keep them still and calm, and look for other injuries.
  3. If the skin is broken, cover the wound and get emergency help right away.
  4. Use a splint or sling to keep the injured area from moving.
  5. Apply ice packs, wrapped in a cloth, to ease pain and swelling.

Do not try to straighten a bone or push it back into place. Do not move someone who may have a neck or back injury.

When to Call 911, Come to the ER, or Watch at Home

Call 911 if the person is not responding, there is severe bleeding, or bone is sticking through the skin. Those are the emergency triggers MedlinePlus lists. Also call 911 after a serious fall or crash with a possible neck or back injury.

Come to the ER if any of these apply:

  • Any of the Ottawa signs above, such as pain right on the ankle bone or not being able to take four steps
  • A limb that looks bent, twisted, or out of place
  • Numbness, tingling, or a cold or pale hand or foot below the injury
  • Pain that is severe or getting worse

Watching at home is reasonable if you can walk, the pain is around the joint rather than on the bone, and swelling is mild. Rest, ice, and elevate it. If it is not getting better, or you are unsure, have it checked.

What Happens at ER of White Rock

A physician examines the injury, checks circulation and nerve function, and applies checks like the Ottawa rules. If imaging is needed, our on-site X-ray and CT means you do not travel elsewhere for it.

Depending on the result, treatment may be a splint, pain control, and a referral to an orthopedic specialist. You leave with written instructions and a follow-up plan. Our fracture care page covers the full workup.

We are open 24 hours at 10705 Northwest Hwy, Dallas, TX 75238, serving White Rock, Lake Highlands, Lakewood, and Casa Linda. Walk in any time or call (469) 943-2939. For a head injury from the same fall, see our guide on when to go to the ER after hitting your head.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can you walk on a broken ankle?

Sometimes. Small breaks can still bear weight with pain, so walking does not rule out a fracture. Not being able to take four steps is one of the Ottawa signs that an X-ray is needed.

Is a hairline fracture an emergency?

A hairline fracture is a small crack in the bone. It is often less dramatic than a full break, but it still needs care. The NIAMS notes that most acute fractures require an immediate visit to a health care provider.

Should my child’s ankle be X-rayed?

The Ottawa rules also work well in children. In the BMJ review, a child who passed the rules had about a 1% chance of a fracture. Children’s growth plates can still be injured, so our parents’ guide explains when to bring them in.

How long should I wait before getting it checked?

Do not wait if you see any sign on this page, such as deformity, numbness, or pain on the bone. For a milder injury, rest it and watch. If it is not improving, or you still cannot walk normally, have it examined.

When is a CT scan needed?

Most bone injuries only need an X-ray. Your physician may order a CT scan for a closer look when a break involves a joint or the X-ray is unclear. Both are available on site.

Written by the ER of White Rock team. Updated September 2026. Read our editorial policy.

Latest Insights: